PM Media Review - Media Blog Covering the Latest News in Movies, Television (TV), Music, and More!
PM Media Review Films Television Music
PM Media Review - Media Blog Covering the Latest News in Movies, Television (TV), Music, and More!
RSS from PM Media Review   PM Media Review Archives Contact PM Media Review
 
Attention Writers! Link To PM Media Review Advertise with PM Media Review
PM Media Review

The Ballad of Jack and Rose
By: Mark Runyon | Category: DVD Archive | 07/15/05 | 08:37 PM
PM Rating System

The Ballad of Jack and RoseGrade: C- | Genre: Independent Drama
Summary: This is an unconventional tale that certainly has its moments, including closing well, yet the story fails to take hold.

Daniel Day-Lewis is a bit of enigma. By all accounts, a brilliant actor who is a bit of a recluse, turned off by the glitz and glamour of the Hollywood machine. He pops out of hiding every so often (Gangs of New York, The Age of Innocence) to remind us that he hasn't completely taken a header off the face of the Earth. It's a shame to blunt this acting talent, but it's a story we've become all too familiar with. Lewis emerges this time for the IFC Films feature The Ballad of Jack and Rose. The film premiered at Sundance in January promising a full-scale release to the art house circuit come the sunny days of summer.

Daniel Day-Lewis shares the spotlight with newcomer Camille Belle in this coming of age tale cemented in change and sacrifice. Lewis plays Jack, a hippie holdover from the late 60s marking the last vestige of a deserted commune. He lives with his teenage daughter, Rose, in virtual isolation on an island off the East Coast. They provide each other with family and companionship, fulfilling most of their needs through living off the land. Their relationship is a bit Oedipal in nature. Rose's mother left when she was 5 and post cards dot their cabin leaving her always a thought away. Rose takes care of Jack and wields fierce jealousy at the mere thought of him being cared for by another woman. Jack, on the other hand, takes to sheltering Rose from the world around her, keeping her from the normality of developing through her teenage years. Their attachment to one another is more than a little creppy.

The Ballad of Jack Rose
The Ballad of Jack and Rose
Starring: Daniel Day-Lewis, Camilla Belle, Catherine Keener, Beau Bridges, Paul Dano, Ryan McDonald & Jena Malone
Director: Rebecca Miller

Email this article to a friend Email this article to a friend
Independent Films
DVD Club for Award-Winning Films
Don't miss out. Join today!
www.filmmovement.com

NETFLIX - Rent Movies
Only $11.99 a month. No Late Fees.
Over 40,000 Titles. Free Trial.
www.netflix.com

Love is complicated.
match.com is simple.
View millions of photos now!
www.match.com

Their tranquil existence gets tossed about when Jack gets sick from a heart ailment. He asks his convenience girlfriend (Keener) to come live with him and Rose. Not being able to resist a wounded man, she uproots her two boys and moves in no questions asked. Jack wins Rose's reluctant approval by telling her that this new living arrangement is "an experiment," fitting the tradition of their lifestyle. The transition proves a rocky one as Rose begins staking out her territory. From poisonous snakes to shotgun blasts, nothing is too small to make her new mum feel welcome. The boy's offer Rose a taste of a life she's never been treated to. Immediately, she wants to dabble in kissing, ditching her virginity and rebelling by snipping off her hair. Jack watches as his daughter evolves at breakneck pace, powerless to muffle the outsider's influence.

Unfortunately for all of Rose's experimentation and wanderings, it isn't a very interesting story. Amy Miller, daughter to famous playwright Arthur Miller, wrote and directed this film. Though the setting and the characters smack together to create sparks of interest, the story ultimately falls flat. Rose's coming of age seems stilted and unrealistic. We don't ever embrace this character enough to really want to see her through these various trials and tribulations. Daniel Day-Lewis is decent in this role though his character appears a bit lost. He struggles with his daughter's newfound freedom; yet his terminal illness never seems to really back up on him. For someone so choosey about his roles, I'm not sure why this one stood out for Lewis. The only real catching point here is the dynamic between the two characters. It has overtones of incest throughout and though the line is flirted with, it is never explicitly crossed.

This is an unconventional tale that certainly has its moments, including closing well, yet the story fails to take hold. Its an eternal waiting game that never bears fruit. With lesser actors in our leads (Lewis and Keener), its doubtful the audience would afford this the patience and effort to see it through to the final reel. So consider the your perfect film when flipping past IFC on a rainy Saturday or, as in my case, a flight from London with 8 hours to dispose of. You can only wheel though you iPod for so long until those ear buds start permanently affixing themselves to your inner ear.

Buy Concert Tickets

Everybody Hates Chris
More
Film Reviews View All
- A History of Violence
- Aeon Flux
- Brokeback Mountain
- Capote
- Chicken Little
- Derailed
- Dreamer
- Elizabethtown
- Flightplan
- Fun with Dick and Jane
- Good Night and Good Luck
- Jarhead
- King Kong
- Kiss Kiss Bang Bang
- Munich
- North Country
- Saw 2
- Syriana
- The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe
- The Family Stone
- The New World
- The Weather Man
- Tim Burton's Corpse Bride
- Two for the Money
- Walk the Line
Music Reviews View All
- 30 Seconds to Mars - A Beautiful Lie
- Blackalicious - The Craft
- Broadcast - Tender Buttons
- Broken Social Scene - Self-Titled
- Cardigans - Super Extra Gravity
- Chocolate Genius Inc - Black Yankee Rock
- Coldplay - X&Y
- David Gray - Life In Slow Motion
- Death Cab for Cutie - Plans
- Depeche Mode - Playing the Angel
- Diana Krall - Christmas Songs
- Editors - The Back Room
- Elbow - Leaders of the Free World
- Franz Ferdinand - You Could Have It So Much Better
- General Elektriks - Cliquety Kliqk
- Gorillaz - Demon Days
- Hard-Fi - Stars of CCTV
- Jack Johnson - In Between Dreams
- Jackson and His Computer Band - Smash
- Jamie Cullum - Catching Tales
- Jamie Lidell - Multiply
- John Cale - blackAcetate
- John Mayer Trio - Try! Live in Concert
- Johnny Cash - The Legend of Johnny Cash
- KT Tunstall - Eye to the Telescope
- Kanye West - Late Registration
- Ladytron - Witching Hour
- My Morning Jacket - Z
- Okkervil River - Black Sheep Boy Appendix EP
- Peter Hammill - Fool's Mate
- Ryan Adams - 29
- Sevendust - Next
- The Black Eyed Peas - Monkey Business
- The High Violets - To Where You Are
- The New Pornographers - Twin Cinema
- The Pussycat Dolls - PCD
- Van Der Graaf Generator - Godbluff
- Van Der Graaf Generator - Still Life
- Various Artists - DFA Holiday Mix 2005
Television Reviews View All
- Arrested Development: Season 3 Premiere
- Boston Legal: Laughs, and Fat, Oh My!
- Criminal Minds or Deja Vu?
- Desperate Housewives: Dark Days Ahead
- Emily's Reasons Why Not: Pilot
- Everybody Hates Chris: Pilot
- Grey's Anatomy: Season 2 Premiere
- Lost: Death of a Survivor
- Making the Band 3: Season Finale
- My Name Is Earl: Pilot
- Nip/Tuck: Is Christian the Carver?
- Nip/Tuck: Season 3 Finale - The Carver Unmasked
- Nip/Tuck: Season 3 Premiere
- Rome: Series Finale
- Scrubs: Season 5 Premiere
- Sleeper Cell: The Terrorist Next Door
- Stacked: Season 2 Premiere
- The Boondocks: Series Premiere
- The Colbert Report: Premiere Week
- The West Wing: Who Won the Debate?
Party Poker
 >  Brokeback Mountain
 >  Neilson Weekly Ratings
01/02/06 - 01/08/06
 >  Emily's Reasons Why Not: Pilot
 >  Iraq Costs Could Top $2 Trillion
 >  Jon Stewart Hosts the Oscars
  Home     Films     Television     Music     Archives     Contact     Advertising   RSS from PM Media Review
 
Copyright © 2008 PM MEDIA REVIEW | Privacy Policy
This site is optimized for the latest versions of Internet Explorer & Netscape
Site maintained by PM Web Solutions